Reindeer Poop: A Silly Stocking Stuffer To Make ... Instructions To make Reindeer Poop, place a handful of malted milk balls or chocolate-covered raisins in a zipper food storage bag or decorated treat bag. Seal bag and label with the printable Reindeer Poop gift tag of your choice. Pre-printed with the Reindeer Poop poem, the tags below will give a professional flair to your handmade holiday gift.